Supporters of the auto bailout insist their intent is not for the government to be running car companies. But it’s clearly a big step in that direction. It would take some decision making away from automakers and give power to a government overseer.
Congressional Democratic leaders and the White House have negotiated a bill to provide $14 billion in emergency short-term loans for Detroit and create a “car czar” to be named by Bush to dole out the loans and oversee restructuring. Democrats hope to pass it by week’s end, but a determined band of congressional GOP foes could still run it into a ditch.
The government has no business managing car companies, even if temporarily, argued Sen. Richard Shelby, R-Ala. “It’s very un-Republican,” he said.
Nearly two years after Bush suggested that Detroit produce “a product that’s relevant” rather than looking for a possible Washington bailout, the president threw his support behind the emergency loans — after wringing a concession from Democrats that the money would come from an existing program to help the industry retool its plants to make greener cars.
Despite Bush’s repeated calls for more free-trade agreements and less international protectionism, the bailout plan would only benefit historical U.S. automakers, not Asian or European ones with plants in the United States.
Advocates of lifting the government’s heavy hand over private business say they are alarmed by the auto plan and other aggressive government moves to impose more regulation, even if the motivation is to keep the recession from deepening.
“The economy will eventually recover. I think policymakers spend too much time thinking about the short-term,” said Chris Edwards, director of fiscal policy for the libertarian Cato Institute. “They should focus on the long term and how do we get investment back to this country.”

